끈기 vs 완고함 / 천재 vs 지능
hackernews
|
|
🔬 연구
#paul graham
#review
#인물비교
#지성
#집착
#끈기
#완고함
#지식인
#천재
원문 출처: hackernews · Genesis Park에서 요약 및 분석
요약
한 작가가 폴 그레이엄의 에세이에서 영감을 받아 지식인에 대한 혐오의 원인을 분석하며, 새로운 영역을 개척하는 '끈기(Persistent)'와 기존 방식을 고수하는 '완고함(Stubborn)'의 차이를 8가지 기준으로 비교했습니다. 또한 순수하고 호기심 많은 '천재(Ingenuous)'가 지적인 '지능(Intelligent)'보다 진정한 돌파구를 만드는 데 유리하다고 주장했습니다. 특히 지능형 인재들은 기존 규칙을 바꾸는 것을 꺼리며, 역사적으로도 마키아벨리, 아비센나, 아인슈타인처럼 아웃사이더가 혁신을 이끈 경우가 많다고 덧붙였습니다.
본문
inspired by a PG essay<p>I spent a week thinking about why I hate intellectuals so much. Here are 2 tables that helped me navigate it. If you have better terminology for all of this, please share.</p><p>| # | Persistent | VS. | Stubborn |
| 1 | Irrational about Problem | Irrational about Process |
| 2 | Curious & Driven | Devout & Driven |
| 3 | Creative | Disciplined |
| 4 | Open Personality | Overwhelmed Personality |
| 5 | Hard to Keep Going | Easy to Stick to |
| 6 | Energetic but Uncertain | Energetic but Certain |
| 7 | Independent Minded | Herd Tolerance |
| 8 | Offensive | Defensive |</p><p>| # | Ingenuous | VS. | Intelligent |
| 1 | Novel | Impressive |
| 2 | Self Doubtful | Self Assured |
| 3 | Universal | Local |
| 4 | Weird | Attractive |
| 5 | Obsessive | Passionate |
| 6 | Independent | Dominant |
| 7 | Simplistic | Sophisticated |
| 8 | Naive | Shrewd |
| 9 | High Altruism | Low Altruism |</p><p>Notes:
1. We can't be persistence without being a little bit stubborn, persistence is good for discovering new territories (ideas) but very bad at keeping them. When we fail, that first impulse of stubbornness is what keeps the ship from collapsing from the doubt allowed by the openness of persistent founders.
2. Ingenuous humans have more in common with curious kids than smart professors, which explains why LLMs are not as good at discover vs. productivity. Opposed to what people think, real breakthroughs don't come from intelligent people. Usually, it's an outsider to academia made insider later to boost prestige (Machiavelli, Avicenna, Einstein). Intelligent people don't like it when the rules changes because they spend decades mastering the old rules.
3. Intelligent people are the best ally of ingenuous kids, not because they are similar but because they mistake ingenuous success as genius.</p>
| 1 | Irrational about Problem | Irrational about Process |
| 2 | Curious & Driven | Devout & Driven |
| 3 | Creative | Disciplined |
| 4 | Open Personality | Overwhelmed Personality |
| 5 | Hard to Keep Going | Easy to Stick to |
| 6 | Energetic but Uncertain | Energetic but Certain |
| 7 | Independent Minded | Herd Tolerance |
| 8 | Offensive | Defensive |</p><p>| # | Ingenuous | VS. | Intelligent |
| 1 | Novel | Impressive |
| 2 | Self Doubtful | Self Assured |
| 3 | Universal | Local |
| 4 | Weird | Attractive |
| 5 | Obsessive | Passionate |
| 6 | Independent | Dominant |
| 7 | Simplistic | Sophisticated |
| 8 | Naive | Shrewd |
| 9 | High Altruism | Low Altruism |</p><p>Notes:
1. We can't be persistence without being a little bit stubborn, persistence is good for discovering new territories (ideas) but very bad at keeping them. When we fail, that first impulse of stubbornness is what keeps the ship from collapsing from the doubt allowed by the openness of persistent founders.
2. Ingenuous humans have more in common with curious kids than smart professors, which explains why LLMs are not as good at discover vs. productivity. Opposed to what people think, real breakthroughs don't come from intelligent people. Usually, it's an outsider to academia made insider later to boost prestige (Machiavelli, Avicenna, Einstein). Intelligent people don't like it when the rules changes because they spend decades mastering the old rules.
3. Intelligent people are the best ally of ingenuous kids, not because they are similar but because they mistake ingenuous success as genius.</p>
Genesis Park 편집팀이 AI를 활용하여 작성한 분석입니다. 원문은 출처 링크를 통해 확인할 수 있습니다.
공유