기본 UI가 견고합니다. 모든 것을 유지할 수는 없습니다.

hackernews | | 📰 뉴스
#ai 딜 #claude #react #shadcn #solidjs #ui 컴포넌트 #생태계
원문 출처: hackernews · Genesis Park에서 요약 및 분석

요약

SolidJS는 React에 비해 성능이 뛰어나지만 UI 컴포넌트 생태계가 부족하여, 저자는 Claude와 Codex 같은 AI 도구를 활용해 SolidJS용 범용 UI 라이브러리를 제작하고자 시도했습니다. 하지만 AI는 독창적인 코드 작성보다는 기존 라이브러리를 단순히 복사하고 변형하는 수준에서만 성과를 보였을 뿐, 복잡한 작업은 중도에 무너지는 한계를 드러냈습니다. 결국 저자는 해당 프로젝트를 폐기하는데, 이는 AI가 코드 생성 비용을 낮춰줄지라도 결국 유지보수에 대한 책임과 부담은 여전히 개발자에게 남기 때문입니다.

본문

I love SolidJS, its just so much better than React, it makes me happy. But the UI components ecosystem in React is just much better, we know this. There are many clones of shadcn, base-ui and many other libs for Solid, Svelte but the quaility is not there. React is better there. Kobalte is not base-ui, its works great! but its not the same. People say code is basically free now. So can AI fix this? Can AI just close this gap? It totally can, they are basically solved problems just with different flavors. So I spent a some money on Claude and Codex (via opencode and pi) to make a base-ui for SolidJS. I made it copy their styles, the examples from radix. I failed badly. Not skill-issues with AI, its not about the code. It just collapsed after a certain point. Multiple attempts from scratch from middle points. A couple of nights of pain, the bad pain, not the âoh i really want this so i am going to push harderâ, nah, it just sucked. Just not worth it. I ended up just telling to copy from Kobalte, that helped a lot and after that it was able to migrate the componets that Kobalte doesnât have. And copy some examples from shadcn and radix. Not a surprise, we know AI can copy well small things. You can find it here: I used it to build multiple apps. It works! But now its archived. Because I donât want to maintain it, its not my thing. You canât maintain everything. Not even if AI makes it so cheap to do, it does! but doesnt make sense! Some companies are lying to themselves thinking that they can support 100x features with the same amount (or 50% less) people because of AI. So, be sure to vibe code stuff you actually want to maintain because you will have to. Somethign that makes you happy. I hope AI can give us a matching experience of React in Solid and Svelte.

Genesis Park 편집팀이 AI를 활용하여 작성한 분석입니다. 원문은 출처 링크를 통해 확인할 수 있습니다.

공유

관련 저널 읽기

전체 보기 →